Monday, May 6, 2013

A Couple Of Stories For Folks To Check.



“Not all renewables are created equal” - By Tom Butler. A post at grist.org, the author does an excellent job of questioning if we are developing the renewable energy industry correctly. Since I live next to one of the largest wind projects in Iowa, I could really identify with this one.  Mr. Butler was discussing the reaction to the book he coedited - ENERGY:Overdevelopment and the Delusion of Endless Growth 

A quote from the grist article - "I’ve found that some green power advocates want to keep it superficial (fossil fuels = bad, renewables = good) rather than digging into tougher questions about appropriate scale and centralized, corporate control of energy resources, including renewables. I am not unsympathetic to the arguments of well-meaning activists who say we can’t let the perfect be the enemy of the “less unsustainable,”

 
And that kind of ties in with -

The Sierra club posted this article provocatively titled   “Warren Buffett's Coal Problem -To run his coal trains, the billionaire investor needs to seize land from a bunch of Montana cowboys. That's not going over very well.” 

Sunday, May 5, 2013

MidAmerican Wind Project Property Tax Update



It’s time for an update on my efforts to determine if MidAmerican Energy Company is paying the correct amount of property taxes in Pocahontas County. I sent the following request to MEC employee Dean Crist.

Dean,
Thanks for sending the property tax information that MEC submitted to the county on the Pomeroy project in Pocahontas County.  We already have this information, as it was available through the Pocahontas county assessor’s office.  
I wanted to clarify that we are looking for additional supporting documentation from MEC to compare with your property tax submissions to the Pocahontas assessor.  We were disappointed to hear that MEC was not willing to make any of the confidential utilities board filings available for review to help us determine if MEC has been assessed the correct amount of property tax for your wind project in Pocahontas county.  I did find an IUB document (attached) that helps explain why we wish to examine these IUB filings. The 2009 Nextera testimony (page21) estimated MidAmerican’s installed cost for wind as high as $2685 per kilowatt. That would give a 1.5 megawatt wind turbine a total installed cost of close to $4 million.  By contrast, the first phase of your wind project installed in Pocahontas county in 2007 is assessed at (I believe) $2.58 million, or slightly over $1700 per KW.  Though wind turbine prices do fluctuate, this seems like a pretty wide difference for a couple of years timeframe, and has several of us here wishing we had access to more information as to how MEC determines property tax in order to estimate if school districts and county are receiving the correct amounts. 

Also note that Nextera (one of the largest wind developers in the country) values its wind assets constructed in that timeframe (page18) higher than MEC, $2150 per kilowatt ( $3.2million) for a 1.5 megawatt turbine.  I have not checked what Nexteras wind assets have been assessed by the counties those properties are located in. 

I appreciate the information MEC has sent so far, and your assurances that all relevant costs in the project were taken into account for your county filings,   but we would like additional information.  We would like information that clearly details what soft costs and construction costs were capitalized and depreciated by this project, potentially adding to the assessed value. Also, a breakdown of turbine costs by foundation, tower and nacelle, transportation to site, and pad transformers.  Your submission to the county does not include an assessment for wire – cable  running between turbines back to the substation, only substation , met tower, land, and turbines.

If we can access this information, we should be better prepared for a call that you offered to set up with the MEC tax department.

Thank you,

I received the following reply from Mr. Crist. The IUB document referenced in my request can be found at the link below

“I was able to spend a little time on your request today.

As communicated before, the cost cap is not what projects were built for; the cap is the approved level we can spend under an IUB order without further prudence review. We have always completed projects at or below the cost caps. NextEra had little clue what our construction costs would be. Remember their interest in that proceeding, in my opinion, was to kill all further wind expansion in Iowa.

I did find some cost caps for the IUB proceedings we mentioned earlier:

  1. The first phase of Pomeroy (123 MW in 2007) was constructed under a Board-approved cost cap of $1,811 per kW.
  2. The second and third phase of the Pomeroy project (75 MW in 2007and 51 MW in 2008, respectively) was constructed under an economic test approved by the Board which resulted in cap caps ranging from $2,230 per kW to $2,480 per kW.
  3. The fourth phase of the Pomeroy project (7.5 MW in 2008) was added with a Board-approved cost cap of $2,300 per kW.
  4. The fifth phase was an addition of 30 MW in the last ratemaking proceeding. At this moment I cannot find what year it was added as projects were added in 2009 – 2012. Cost caps for these projects were $2,050 per kW in 2009, $2,200 per kW for 2010 and $2,300 per kW for 2011-2012.

I also include the actual costs by wind farm (not cost caps) on pages 410 and 411 of FERC Form 1.  See attached for cost as of 12/31/2012. I have highlighted the Pomeroy project.

I can find nothing more to supply at this point. “

I’m reviewing the FERC document, but really, this just raises additional issues to the ones listed in other posts on this subject.  My understanding is that the Pomeroy Project has only three different property tax rates, but Dean mentions the utilities board cost cap for this project was adjusted 5 different times.

I didn’t get any of the itemized costs I asked for yet.

As for Deans comments that Nextera was trying to kill all future wind development in Iowa, WOW!
My understanding of IUB DOCKET NO. RPU-09-0003 was that it was an argument between Nextera and MEC over who got to build a wind expansion project in Iowa, MEC won. Only these two companies know the inside details of this big wind fight.  

Two things seem certain however.
1-      MEC recently opposed further expansion of wind in Iowa when they registered against SF372, the farmer owned energy bill that did not advance at the legislature this year. Nextera only monitored it.
2-      I still haven’t gotten to the bottom of this property tax issue.  



Saturday, May 4, 2013

Did Your Electricity Stay On During The Snowstorm?



Mine did, though several neighbors lost theirs, but that's a story for another day.

If you were one of the many unlucky Iowans who lost electricity during our May snowstorm, you might want to advocate for better distributed generation (DG) policy in our state. It’s becoming much easier and cost effective to have emergency power combined with your renewable energy system. However, the mix of policy around Iowa continues to hamper residents who wish to install DG systems, despite the fact that DG technology is clearly ready for primetime.   

So today, I want to pass on this link, an op-ed by Amory Lovins.  Here’s a fun quote of his from the article-  “How to End Blackouts Forever” -    “By my accounting, a resilient, microgrid-based, and 80%-renewable electricity system would cost about the same as business-as-usual, greatly strengthening national and family security as a free bonus.”  Something to consider as our country contemplates how to update our decades old national grid and centralized power plant system.

Probably one of the earliest advocates for distributed generation, Lovins also “walks the walk”.  Living high in the Rockies, his house is powered by a grid tied solar PV system, complete with backup power.  He raises bananas in his 1980’s mountain home.  I thought I would dedicate a post to him, as the rest of the world starts to catch up to what he has been advocating for since the 80’s.  He coauthored one of the first books on remaking our century old electric grid into a more resilient, distributed one. While looking for links for this post, I came across this book, “Brittle Power”, which can be downloaded here. 

Amory also took issue recently with a statement made by President Obama during an interview with the New Republic. You might want to check out “Climate Change: No Breakthroughs Needed, Mr. President”.  Looks like Amory thinks that barriers to addressing climate change are political rather than technological. Maybe the President should have considered him for energy secretary. Amory also seems to believe that addressing climate change will be profitable for the U.S. and its citizens. Even though he is discussing wonky, big, issues, that when a lot us usually read about them, our eyes quickly start to glaze over, we “Mere Mortals” will appreciate how he cuts through all the wonk stuff with quotes like “Don’t worry, beer will still be cold and showers still hot when we switch to renewables”.  His website can be found here.  
  
Enjoy!

Monday, April 29, 2013

Colorado Legislators Strengthen Renewable Policy



More links today. While Iowa is on track to do nothing for distributed renewables this year, Colorado legislators bucked heavy utility opposition and strengthened their state clean energy standard. It looks like Minnesota will do the same. Hey Iowa senators, just because there is a lot of installed wind in Iowa (quite a bit of it serving renewable mandates in other states), doesn’t mean you’re leading in in renewable policy. 

Reader question- Can anyone supply me with figures showing how much of Iowa’s wind energy is exported and how much serves in state electrical load?   

Cool tech link – new solar design ups PV output by capturing waste heat for water.

Cool policy link – Germans pay about the same per month for electricity as U.S. citizens. Craig Morris has been writing some excellent articles on renewables.
Germany - 25% renewable energy – U.S. – 4% renewables.

Friday, April 26, 2013

Nebraska enviro group claims that state lost data center because of Iowa Wind .





Today , a couple of links that definitely clash with each other.  Nebraska Sierra club thinks the “data center” went to Iowa because of available wind capacity.   But, the group will not be glad to see this story. The social media CEO has a political group that is advocating for Keystone XL.      
Thanks to Steven Lacey and Midwest Energy News for these links